Reviews

I was in the area for a wrestling ...
I was in the area for a wrestling tournament. I asked the hotel receptionist for a recommendation so i ended up here. I must say it was a great recommendation. I got the Blue Crab Mini Feast. It came with 5 blue crab, 1 piece of fried chicken, corn, hush puppies, clam strips(I don't eat clam). The carbs were the perfect sizes and sea ... read more
Wendy J. via yelp.com - May 8, 2017
Great place to meet,and dine ... read more
Joseph Sylvester via google.com - Feb 9, 2017
best dagom crab i very had down yonder in maryland ... read more
Brian Henry via google.com - Feb 2, 2017
Great food and drinks ... read more
Megan DiPrima via google.com - Jan 2, 2017
Best food ever!
Joyvan Malbon via google.com - Dec 2, 2016
I Love Old Mill Crab. That are the 🎉🎊😍😘😋😂🤗💣🍤🍽🐟🦀❤️GOOD.
Louvenia Nichols via google.com - Oct 2, 2016
This was an amazing experience the waitresses were polite and fast with our orders and we had an abundance for real good food. I will be back ... read more
Jean Randall via google.com - Sep 2, 2016
Old Mill Crab House is the place to go for Maryland style crabs. ... read more
TheEdelfranco via google.com - Sep 2, 2016
Stumbled on this place after leaving ...
Stumbled on this place after leaving Dogfish Head Brewery and heading to outer banks. So glad we did! While it was a 45 minute wait, it was well worth it. We got beers for less than 3 bucks each. When we were seated My friend and I split the snow crab mini feast and has shrimp and it was an insane amount of food. At one point a waitr ... read more
Calee P. via yelp.com - Aug 11, 2016
Been coming here 12 years always good ... read more
Rick Irwin via google.com - Aug 2, 2016
Now I know why I have fond memories of crab houses from years ago. The one is worth the trip.
Richard Polk via google.com - Aug 2, 2016
I love how stupid some of the people posting negative reviews are. If you get filled up on all the fried goodness they give you before the crab comes out don't complain that you're full when the seafood hits the table. This just means you're a moron and glutton that can't wait for your main meal. As to this restaurant it is by fa ... read more
S Martin via google.com - Aug 2, 2016
Great place for blue crabs!  We ...
Great place for blue crabs!  We had the mini crab feasts and it was awesome.  We were seated right away & the wait staff was very friendly and super attentive.  Very accommodating for our toddler too.  Definitely recommend this place!
Mike Z. via yelp.com - Jul 4, 2016
Love this place!
starlene sutton via google.com - Jul 2, 2016
I love this place ... read more
Janile Trappier via google.com - Jul 2, 2016
This is a wonderful Crab restaurant! I finally was able to come here after being told of its legend by my inlaws. Price and value were reasonable. Crabs were meaty, service was outstanding and atmosphere was fun. BTW, if you're not looking for an all you can eat experience, the mini feast is an excellent value.
Charles Willcutt via google.com - Jul 2, 2016
Love it people friends ... read more
Loretta Smith via google.com - Jul 2, 2016
If you're looking for a good crab ...
If you're looking for a good crab feast, this is where it's at! Plenty of food to indulge in and very helpful and attentive staff. The wait was very quick and the food was well worth the money! Blue crabs, fried shrimp, fried chicken, corn on the cob, hush puppies, fries, crab dip and pretzel bites with beer to accommodate the food w ... read more
Joy T. via yelp.com - Jun 19, 2016
Excellent old style crab shack dining. Although $$$ ... read more
Harry Skelton via google.com - Jun 2, 2016
This place is great! I would recommend ...
This place is great! I would recommend getting the all you can eat specials it's worth it.The waitress was very attentive. The only thing is they threw away a lot of food. The shrimp,crabs,hush puppies,corn,crab legs,clams and chicken were great. I ordered a mango smoothie and that was good too. I have no complaints about this place.
Morgan G. via yelp.com - May 30, 2016
Was there about 12 years ago wife and I fell in love with the place the food was awesome I've never had better Fried Chicken Maryland Fried Chicken in my life it was awesome we're hoping to get there this year if we can if we're in Ocean City right now and we're talking about stopping there on the way home for supper tomorrow night s ... read more
Don Smith via google.com - May 2, 2016
Everything was delicious.
Linda Bennett via google.com - Apr 2, 2016
The food is always hot seasoned to the MAX!!! SERVED WITH WARMNESS OF HEART!!!! It makes dinning Delightful ♡♥ ... read more
Delores Smith via google.com - Apr 2, 2016
I love going here we come in a very large group and we love every minute of it ... read more
Ina Harris via google.com - Mar 2, 2016
Awesome crab experience! The Poole's ... read more
Chantell Ellis via google.com - Mar 2, 2016
Great food and experience, get here early or wait in line. Top 3 seafood buffet ... read more
Isaiah Tindle via google.com - Mar 2, 2016
THE ABSOLUTE BEST SEAFOOD SPOT I'VE EVER BEEN TO. ALREADY PLANNING MY SECOND TRIP BACK!!!! Everything tastes anazing!!!!
Lawrence Valentine via google.com - Mar 2, 2016
What didn't I like? ... read more
Angela Smith via google.com - Mar 2, 2016
I love the service you get with all you can eat! The waitresses are very good & fast with keeping large tables of customers happy. Excellent place to eat.
Tracy Heathman via google.com - Mar 2, 2016
We've been going there since the 90's. Great food! Great people! Beautiful, tranquil location! A must if you're in Maryland!
Judi LeHuquet via google.com - Mar 2, 2016
Everything 😍 ... read more
Chardon Roundtree via google.com - Mar 2, 2016
Great place to gather the family , crabs and cold beer ... read more
Mark Ryer via google.com - Mar 2, 2016
Found this gem through some locals ...
Found this gem through some locals that live here. Crappy part is that we all live in the Dover area so we have to drive over an hour to get here but that speaks to how much it is worth it. The all you can eat crab legs are amazing! And the fried chicken, fried shrimp, clam strips and hush puppies are amazing too. Get there when they ... read more
Bobby J. via yelp.com - Sep 28, 2015
So my girlfriend has spoke about ...
So my girlfriend has spoke about this place to me for awhile and I told her next time we are in Ocean city we would visit them. How ever come to find out the Ocean city location is closed. With that said we spent the last weekend of August in OCMD. First night there we decided to do dinner at old mill. I was skeptical because it was ... read more
Edson P. via yelp.com - Aug 30, 2015
Being this was my first time eating ...
Being this was my first time eating here my MC we took a ride out here for crabs and was not disppointed the food was delicious and the service was great and the waitresses were friendly and very professional..on Sundays just make sure you get there before 3pm because there was a long line out the door for people waiting to get in lo ... read more
Jack K. via yelp.com - Aug 24, 2015
Outstanding! The loudest restaurant ...
Outstanding! The loudest restaurant I've ever been to and I loved it. Sounds of talking laughing and hammers beating crab claws! Absolutely fantastic food. All you can eat blue crab! Served so there are always HOT crabs on the table. Highly recommend and will return again and again!
Emma S. via yelp.com - Aug 16, 2015
Had such a fun night! This is a ...
Had such a fun night! This is a true dining experience with yummy food! Gabby was fabulous! She showed this newbie how to pick blue crab and snow crab! And you have to try the funnel fries! Amazing!! If you are in Salisbury you must dine here!!!
Katie S. via comhttp - Jul 6, 2015
I could make  6 meals out of the ...
I could make  6 meals out of the mini feast! When I want crabs,  this is my go to place! Fresh crabs,  sweet hush puppies,  sweet buttery corn on the cob,  crusty fried chicken,  clams,  and huge fried shrimp!!! OH MY!!!
Mikki K. via comhttp - Jun 1, 2015
This has been a staple spot for ...
This has been a staple spot for my entire family. I have even brought people from work and church, friends, EVERYBODY. All you can eat snow crabs or blue crabs with hush puppies (extra powdered sugar), fried chicken, fried shrimp, clam strips, hot corn on the cob, $35 BUCKS!!! get drinks like beer and regular beverages by the pitcher ... read more
Jasmine J. via comhttp - Apr 6, 2015
The crabs are amazing. We live ...
The crabs are amazing. We live on the Eastern Shore and my 4 kids, wife, and I can eat crabs anywhere, but the Old Mill is where we go! They've got phenomenal crabs and the staff is always great. Mom is happy, because they're tolerant of our little kids making a mess and I'm happy because the beer is cold and the crabs are piping hot ... read more
Carlos A. via comhttp - Oct 29, 2014
My girlfriend and I went here for ...
My girlfriend and I went here for my birthday 8.29.14 and WE LOVED IT!!!! We arrived at 5:10 pm on a Friday evening. The parking lot was already full. We got seated right away and our waitress was amazing her name was Sarah. She checked in with us faithfully. Our table was never empty. I got the AYCE Crabs and she got AYCE crab legs.
Alicia H. via comhttp - Sep 16, 2014
Found this gem on our way to OBX ...
Found this gem on our way to OBX. Great atmosphere and fantastic food at a reasonable price. We had the Blue Crab, Shrimp, Clams combo. Very very good crab. Shrimp were delicious and clams were spot on. Hush puppies rounded out a great meal.
David H. via comhttp - Aug 9, 2014
Run don't walk to this restaurant! ...
Run don't walk to this restaurant!  I wasn't sure what to expect when the hush puppies came out with powdered sugar sprinkled on top, but I was so happy once I popped one in my mouth. From then on there was a party in my mouth with each dish I tasted! The crab dip was tasty; the salty pretzels were a bit much, but the dip was delicio ... read more
Linda O. via comhttp - Jul 10, 2014
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
Google+FoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip Advisor